News and Articles

Immigration Status and Employment Laws in New York

Yogi Patel - Wednesday, February 27, 2019


Foreign workers in the U.S. occupy every position from farmhand and dishwasher to engineer, doctor and CEO, and their visas and legal statuses also vary greatly. For the majority of the twelve-plus million undocumented immigrants, there is no such thing as legal employment, and therefore employers are not supposed to hire them at all. As we all know, this invisible working class drives the service and agricultural industries and exploitation of these workers is integral to expanding the profit margins for many U.S. employers. It is the employers who are at-risk in these cases, as they are not complying with the federal government’s E-verify program, which requires that they confirm work eligibility before they hire foreign workers. Workers in these cases have very limited rights. Their employment is generally “at-will”, however, despite this status (which is discussed in more detail below), employees are still protected by labor laws in most states. As an example, irrespective of your immigration status, an employee that is not paid overtime can assert a claim under state and federal law for under payment or non-payment.

Further across the spectrum between undocumented foreign workers and dual nationals (foreign nationals who also become U.S. citizens), there are workers with temporary work visas, from the seasonal workers on H-2B visas to the E-1/E-2, H-1B, P and L visas, who are generally bound to one employer which sponsors them and have limits on their duration (from several months up to 5, 6 or 7 years, depending on the visa). What is complicated with these visas is if the employees are laid off, there may not be a grace period to seek new employment and thus maintain legal status, and they be forced to leave the country. O-1 visa holders may have agent sponsors which allows them to work more independently, and can change sponsors for future renewals.

Spouses of E and L visa holders can get employment authorization documents (EADs) which allow them to get lawful employment with any company, but the length of the EADs is tied to the duration of their spouse’s legal status. H-1 and O-1 spouses are ineligible for EADs. Once a foreign national obtains legal permanent residence or U.S. citizenship, they cannot lose this legal status if they lose their job. So how does all this fit in with employment laws?
The majority of workers in New York, and the United States in general, are subject to the at-will employment doctrine. This judicially created at-will rule to employment law states, "where an employment is for an indefinite term it is presumed to be a hiring at-will which may be freely terminated by either party, at any time, for any reason, or for no reason." The at-will doctrine has been entrenched in employment law for almost a century and a half and the most practical effect of it is that American employees are subject to being freely terminated for any reason, or for no reason at all - provided that the termination is not for a discriminatory reason. Therefore, an employer can terminate an employee simply because they do not like the color of an employee’s shirt, however, the employer cannot terminate an employee because of the employee’s race, national origin, religion, disability, pregnancy and other enumerated protected categories under city, state and federal law.

The at-will rule is viewed as an equitable approach to employment termination decisions. The rationale is that because it grants the employer the right to terminate, at any time, for any reason - it also provides the employee with that same right; accordingly, an at-will employee has the right to quit, at any time, for any reason.

There are some narrow exceptions to this judicially created rule in New York. The first exception is the "handbook exception” which stands for the proposition that an employer could still be liable for arbitrarily discharging an employee if the employee can establish that the employer had a written policy limiting its right of discharge, which the employee was both aware of and relied detrimentally on in accepting the employment. Therefore, language in an employment contract or employee handbook could impact the at-will doctrine. The second exception is a narrow professional exception that applies only to members of the New York State bar (attorneys) that are involved in reporting misconduct that is mandated by the Code of Professional Responsibility. The third and last exception was promulgated by the New York State Legislature and is known as the "whistleblower exception." The "whistleblower exception" has been interpreted, by New York's highest court, to protect only those employees who report violations that endanger public health or safety.

Thus, short of these three narrow exceptions, the doctrine of at-will employment governs the relationship between employers and employees in New York State and an employer can terminate an employee for any reason or no reason, provided it is not for a discriminatory reason.

For more questions regarding employment law please contact Yogi Patel, Esq., at For any immigration questions please contact Steve Maggi, Esq., at


Recent Posts


Westchester County implementing new leave laws commuter benefits Glatt v. Fox Searchlight Pictures, Inc. Westchester Safe and Sick Time Laws Non-Qualified Stock Options Overtime Rules Household Employees Executive Negotiation Web Domains Employer Mandate Worker's Rights Employment Contracts Facebook Privacy and Litigation Illegal rentals Affordable Care Act Unionization Trade Secrets Womens Rights Federal Contractors Apple vs. FBI Trade Secrets Act Start-up Ventures Federal Joint Employer Rule Freelance Isn't Free Housing Law Landlord-Tenant Law NYC Salary History Law Sexual Harassment Overtime Exemptions Security Fair Chance Act Health Care Postnup Hairstyle Discrimination sexual harassment training Fair Labor Standards Act Sexual Harassment policy NY payroll law stocks COVID-19 workplace discrimination drug testing Fair Pay and Safe Workplace Executive Order #meToo Browning-Ferris Case Unions Public-Sector Union Fees Credit Checks Executive Severance Nanny Audit Alter-Ego Doctrine AirBnB Paycheck Protection Program Lactation Law Domain Name Prenup marijuana usage National Labor Relations Board Fair Work Week Legislation Arbitration Agreements Employee Salary Histories New York Earned Sick Time Act Business graduate students Families First Coronavirus Response Act Real Estate Law EEOC Filing Requirement Divorce Department of Labor Interns federal Department of Labor Human Rights Law National Labor Relations Act Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) Internet Law Interview Series Wage and Hour Law Ban the Box Salary History Inquiries New York City Human Rights Law Marijuana Testing Trademark licensing Corporate Law Independent Contractor LinkedIn Webinar NYC Sick Leave Law Credit History Immigration Status Emergency Economic Injury Grants NLRB Criminal Record Fair Play to Pay Act I-9 Verification employment discrimination lawsuits Workplace Requirements U.S. Department of Labor Trademark Law NYC Sexual harrassment law Sexual Harassment and Discrimination In The Workplace Joint-Employer Relationship Interns as Employees Intellectual Property Employment Offer/Agreement Transgender protections Payroll Scams Federal Acquisition Regulatory Council Fair Workweek Law ACA Mandatory Class Action Waivers Right to Unionize Economic Injury Disaster Loans Plastic Bag Ban Privacy Employee Manuals and Policies Minimum wage Federal Small Business Assistance NYC Human Right's Law's Pregnancy Negotiating Business Law $15 Minimum Wage NQSO Federal Overtime Law Employment Law entrepreneur Tax-Deferred Savings Wage Theft Protection Act Credit Attracting Investment Out-of-State LLC Owners Firm Announcements Nobel Prize New Address Newsletter Glatt v. Fox Searchlight Pictures Technology Selling Business Paid Family Leave


EDIT - blog-container - This controls the styles for the headings

EDIT - BlogTagCloud - Font style


  • EDIT  - post-body - Font style

EDIT - side-panel - This is the colour of the sidebar headings

Snap | BC Module - Blog - Blog Description

Snap | BC Module - Blog - Blog Title

EDIT - Snap | BC Module - Blog - Date - This is the date box style

EDIT - Snap | BC Module - Blog - Post Content - Font style

EDIT - Snap | BC Module - Blog - Post Title - Heading style

EDIT  - Snap | BC Module - Blog - Sidebar Content - Font style

EDIT - Snap | BC Module - Blog - Sidebar Title - Heading style

latest blog title snap text


Disclaimer: Nothing on this website is or should be construed as legal advice.
An attorney-client relationship does not exist with our firm unless a signed
retainer agreement is executed, and we do not offer legal advice through
this site or any of the content located on it. For legal advice for your
particular circumstances, please contact us directly.